Lets' give formatives the boot

Jul 11 / Belinda-lee Heydenrych
A New Era of QCTO-Aligned Learning
For years, South Africa's legacy qualifications under the SETA model have leaned heavily on portfolios of evidence built through countless formative tasks—worksheets, checklists, reflections, and logbooks. While the intention was to guide learning, the unintended result in many cases has been a system bloated with paperwork and light on actual learning. Quantity overshadowed quality, and learners often became more concerned with collecting signatures than mastering skills.


Now, with the rise of QCTO Occupational Qualifications, we’re entering a new era—one where the end goal is clear: the External Integrated Summative Assessment (EISA). This assessment, overseen by an Assessment Quality Partner (AQP), is the official measure of a learner’s occupational competence. It's national, standardised, and high-stakes. And here's the kicker: there's no formal requirement for formative assessments to be included in the portfolio of evidence at all.
This isn’t to say formative assessment is dead—it just means its role has changed.
From Evidence Gathering to Exam Preparation
In the QCTO model, formative assessments are no longer an administrative ritual. They’re not compliance checkboxes. Instead, they become targeted practice: a strategic tool to prepare learners for the final assessment. Their new purpose is twofold:
Application of Knowledge – ensuring learners understand and can apply what they’re learning in real-world contexts.
Testing Readiness – providing facilitators and learners with feedback on how well-prepared they are for the EISA or final AQP assessment.
In many QCTO qualifications, there’s no specified format for formative activities. This freedom should be used wisely: design mini-tests and simulations that mirror the structure, difficulty, and intent of the summative assessment. Every activity should have a direct link to the curriculum outcomes and Internal Assessment Criteria (IACs).

Formative Tasks Should Look Like Tests

If a module ends with a test, that test should look and feel like the real exam. It should be marked, discussed, and reflected upon. The results of these mini-assessments form a credible picture of learner progress—not through endless paperwork, but through focused, meaningful feedback.
No more:
"Write a paragraph and stick it in your file."
"Complete a checklist just to show we did something."
Instead:
"Here’s a 15-mark case study similar to what you’ll face in the EISA—let’s go through it together."
"This scenario mirrors your workplace module—show me how you’d solve it."
In this model, the outcome of the formative test should help facilitators decide: Is the learner ready to move on, or do they need intervention?
Pass Marks Should Reflect the AQP’s Benchmark
Another shift: the pass mark for formative assessments should mirror the AQP’s pass mark, which is often set at 50% or 60%, depending on the occupational qualification. If learners pass formative assessments set at that level, we Formative Tasks

Should Look Like Tests

If a module ends with a test, that test should look and feel like the real exam. It should be marked, discussed, and reflected upon. The results of these mini-assessments form a credible picture of learner progress—not through endless paperwork, but through focused, meaningful feedback.
No more:
"Write a paragraph and stick it in your file."
"Complete a checklist just to show we did something."
Instead:
"Here’s a 15-mark case study similar to what you’ll face in the EISA—let’s go through it together."
"This scenario mirrors your workplace module—show me how you’d solve it."
In this model, the outcome of the formative test should help facilitators decide: Is the learner ready to move on, or do they need intervention?
Pass Marks Should Reflect the AQP’s Benchmark
Another shift: the pass mark for formative assessments should mirror the AQP’s pass mark, which is often set at 50% or 60%, depending on the occupational qualification. If learners pass formative assessments set at that level, we c an be confident they’re progressing toward competence.
This aligns the entire learning journey to the actual measure that matters—the final assessment. It also removes the disconnect between “formatively competent” and “EISA fail”—a gap we’ve seen far too often under the legacy system.

The Facilitators New Role

Facilitators now act more like exam coaches than portfolio managers. They curate activities that:
Build deep understanding.
Encourage application and critical thinking.
Mimic the EISA environment.
Offer clear, honest feedback.
This doesn’t require more admin—it requires smarter design. Activities must be linked to learning outcomes, carefully scaffolded, and timed. They must teach, test, and prepare.

In Summary: Burn the Old Rulebook

The QCTO has not mandated traditional formative assessments. That silence is an opportunity, not a loophole. It’s a call to redefine formative learning in a way that truly benefits learners—through relevant, rigorous, and practical preparation.
It’s time to give legacy-format formatives the boot.
Let’s replace them with purpose-driven, curriculum-aligned tasks that truly prepare learners for the final test—and the world of work beyond.
Created with